Facial recognition and combating crime: why biases can lead to a justice system full of prejudices

Facial recognition and combating crime: why biases can lead to a justice system full of prejudices

My list

Author | Arantxa HerranzAn increasing number of cities are turning to facial recognition systems as a measure to combat crimeMoscow is one of the most recent, but before reaching the Russian capital, they could be found in cities such as Chicago or countries such as China. A measure that has had its fair share of controversy, since defenders of civic freedoms and privacy fear that technology will become a massive surveillance and, more importantly, a discriminatory weapon. Europe, in fact, is considering prohibiting the use of facial recognition systems in public spaces for five years, until measures are put in place designed, precisely, to prevent possible abuses.The problem is not so much whether this is an imperfect system (in china, for example, there is a certain degree of controversy since it was noted that at the entrance to buildings with facial recognition, people wearing masks to prevent the spread of the coronavirus are being denied access); part of the controversy is that facial recognition has significant racial, sexual and age biases.

Middle aged white men, the most recognisable

Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology discovered that the facial recognition algorithms are much better with people described as white than with Afro-American or Asian people. So much so, that the errors in the identification of these people are 10 to 100 times more likely of failing than with Caucasian faces.In a database of photos used by police agencies in the United States, the highest error rates came in identifying Native Americans, according to the study. Furthermore, the algorithms had more difficulties in identifying women than men.To conduct this study, the agency tested around 200 facial recognition algorithms of around 100 developers, using four collections of photographs with over 18 million images of more than 8 million people.Facial recognition

Biases are maximised in artificial intelligence

The problem of biases is not new. And it is not the only one in artificial intelligence. But the main problem is that algorithms may, when badly programmed, maximise and increase these biases that affect people’s race, age, condition and sexual orientation or religion.And it not does not just affect facial recognition: a recent study also demonstrated that an algorithm widely used in hospitals in the US to assign medical care to patients has been systematically discriminating against black people.In many cases, AI can reduce the subjective interpretation of human data, since algorithms learn to only consider variables that improve their predictive accuracy, based on the training data used. Furthermore, there is significant evidence to suggest that AI models can embed human and social biases and deploy them at scale.Therefore, both humans and machines should strive to avoid biases and, with them, discrimination. Biases in AI occur mainly in data or algorithmic models, therefore the industry is looking to develop AI systems that we can trust. These systems therefore need to be trained with impartial data, developing algorithms that can be easily explained for possible analysis when false positives are identified.Images | Fauxels, teguhjatipras

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

YB
Yenesew Alene Belew
University of Gondar
General Manager
JM
Juan pablo Melo
Sambo
President
AA
Abdulla Ebrahim Al Ahmed
Etisalat
Senior Vice President Government Sales
RB
Richard Baamonde
CJIS GROUP LLC
Sales for a research company focused on uncovering tech procurement opportunities in US SLED Market
MS
Mario Segers
Seris Technology
Pre Sales
JG
John Goy
BT
Account Director
DC
de Brito Christophe
ADI Global
Technical Expert
MA
Manuel Ayala
Praga Technology SAC
Manager
DR
Daniel Ralph
BT
BO
Belén Olarte
Multimedios Regional SA
ME
Monica Eremia
U.S. Embassy Bucharest
Advisory
DV
Diego Vega
ITELCA
Marketing Manger
AB
Alison Brooks
IDC
Research VP - Smart Cities & Communities - Public Safety
MP
Mariano Picone
donner servicios s.a.
President & Founder
SB
Sukhdev Bhogal
Flir ITS
Business Development UK, IE, Nordic and India region
YZ
Yulia Zharinova
RTI
Manager
MR
MIQUEL RIBAS GARAU
Familiar
Senior
LK
Lucky Khanna
PIET
Student and Department Representor
AC
Aubrie Cresswell
unifi.id
Head of U.S. Business Development
AT
Asan Tokpanov
AiFund
Project Manager